Comparative literature and compare-and-contrast essay: A trajectory of confusions

comparative literature compare‑and‑contrast literary comparison trajectory of confusion

Authors

Downloads

Both comparative literature and the compare‑and‑contrast essay involve the act of comparison, yet they serve different purposes and operate within distinct frameworks. Comparative literature emphasizes the analysis of literary works in relation to social, cultural, political, and ideological contexts across nations and languages. It requires interdisciplinary approaches. Comparative literature also reveals the essential values of the literary works’ messages. In contrast, the compare‑and‑contrast essay is mainly a composition skill aimed to present logical arguments about similarities and differences between two objects of any kinds, including literary texts, without necessarily engaging varied theoretical views. Though comparative literature necessarily involves comparing literary works, not all literary comparisons qualify as comparative literature. This has often been misunderstood, leading many scholars to wrongly take into account a simple compare‑and‑contrast writing as a valid comparative literary analysis. This paper is intended to disclose the true concepts of the two subjects and reveal the backgrounds of many scholars misapplying these concepts. Using a qualitative method and drawing on the theories of comparative literature, this study finds out that there are two main causes of their being on a trajectory of confusion: the ambiguity of the term “compare” and the obscurity encompassing the theoretical foundations of comparative literature. A more accurate understanding of the differences of the two subjects will guide scholars toward more appropriate analyses of literary works throughout nations, languages, and cultures within the framework of comparative literature.